Political email, explained
Opt-in, rented and voter-file email lists: what is the difference?
The three differ in where the email addresses came from and what the people behind them agreed to. That decides who may send to them, whether you get the addresses, and how the email is likely to land.
Updated
Where each kind comes from
- A voter file. The official list of registered voters that each state keeps for running elections. What it holds, and who may get it, depends on the state. Many voter files carry no email address, and some states hold back the ones they have.
- An email-matched voter file. A voter file with email addresses added by matching names and home addresses to records from other sources. Ask where the email addresses came from and whether those people agreed to receive email.
- A rented list. A list someone else built and keeps. You pay for a send, and the list owner sends your email to it. You usually never see the addresses.
- An opt-in audience. People who agreed to receive email from third parties, reached through a managed send. You choose the place and the people, approve the email, and it is sent for you.
What the people on it agreed to
Consent shapes the results. Email to people who never agreed draws more spam reports, and mailbox providers move a sender with many reports out of the inbox.
- On a voter file, a person registered to vote. Registering is not agreeing to email.
- On a rented list, it depends on how that list was built. Ask to see the sign-up wording.
- On an opt-in audience, each person agreed to receive email from third parties.
Party on a list: registered or modeled
Some states record each voter’s party when they register, and many do not. Where a state does not, a list marks party with a model: a score of how likely a person is to lean one way.
Ask which one a count uses. In our counts, Republicans means registered Republicans plus people modeled as conservative-leaning, and Democrats means registered Democrats plus people modeled as liberal-leaning, so each is larger than that party’s registration alone.
Which fits your campaign
How each option is priced, its usual minimum and whether you get the list are side by side on our comparison page.
- Your own supporters: your own list, built from your website and events.
- Mail, phones and door knocking as well as email: voter records from a voter-file vendor, under its license terms.
- New people in a place you choose, by email: a rented list or an opt-in audience through a managed send, with a count first.
Questions and answers
Does a voter file include email addresses?
Often not. Many state voter files carry no email address, and some states hold back the ones they have, so vendors add one by matching other records. Ask where an added address came from and whether that person agreed to email.
What is the difference between a rented list and an opt-in audience?
With both, the email is sent for you and you do not get the addresses. The difference is in how the people joined: an opt-in audience is made of people who agreed to receive email from third parties, while a rented list depends on how its owner built it.
Check the numbers yourself
- The Opt-In Reach Index. Opt-in email records in every state and D.C., with the date each was counted and a free download.
- The free district count. How to count the opt-in voters in any congressional district, free.
- Run a free count. Count any place and audience in the app, live. To see the final number you confirm your name and email.